hspn reviews
 

Categories
Search


Advanced Search
Advertisement

Article Options
Popular Articles
  1. Will Installing It Void My Warranty
  2. Engine Management Is The Smartest Bang for The Buck on The STi
  3. Selecting a Catback Exhaust for my STI
  4. Searching for a Lightweight One-Piece Driveshaft.
  5. The History of the Mitsubishi Evolution
No popular articles found.
Popular Authors
  1. Kevin Lawrence
  2. Michael Anthony
  3. Nick Luhr
  4. Brian Beckman
  5. Alex Racanelli
  6. Josh Fowler
  7. Drift.com
  8. Aaron Ekinaka
  9. Ben Fried
No popular authors found.

 »  Home  »  Product Reviews  »  Subaru  »  Impreza (RS, WRX, STI)  »  Engine Management Is The Smartest Bang for The Buck on The STi
Engine Management Is The Smartest Bang for The Buck on The STi
By Nick Luhr | Published  01/4/2006 | Impreza (RS, WRX, STI) | Rating:
Piggyback Solutions
The term “piggyback” is used to describe an engine management solution that works in conjunction with the stock ECM.  The most popular piggyback on the market for STI’s is the TurboXS UTEC.  There are some inherent strengths and weaknesses with a piggyback system, especially with the UTEC.  Namely, the UTEC offers launch control and static timing.  Some would say the static timing is good because of consistency, but I would contend that it is an absolute flaw because it offers little to no protection against knock if something happens that puts your tuning into the wrong side of things.  The UTEC will knock every single pull if you let it, whereas the stock system will knock once, realize it, and then not even attempt to run that timing combination again until much later, hopefully by which time, you’ve fixed the problem.  This highlights the inherent strength and intelligence of the stock ECM – its ability to learn and adapt.  Piggyback solutions are supposed to be cheap, easy, and fairly effective, but the UTEC is expensive ($1000), difficult (there really is not such thing as “easy”), and it is effective, but only if static timing or launch control is something you desire. 

Other piggyback solutions include the XEDE from Vishnu Tuning and Unichip from Dastek.  The XEDE is even more expensive than the UTEC if you want its best features, which is the adaptability upgrade known as SMART which isn’t even available yet.  The single most annoying thing about piggyback systems though, is due to the inherent design flaw that makes them ‘piggyback’ to begin with.  They utilize the factory ECM’s tuning for closed loop operation and switch to their own internal tuning for open loop operation.  This results in a persistent and impossible-to-tune-out hesitation at varying load/throttle positions where the system switches from ECM control to Piggyback control.
Comments
  • Comment #1 (Posted by an unknown user)
    Rating
    Excellent article with some great advice.
     
  • Comment #2 (Posted by an unknown user)
    Rating
    Thanks for contributing this. It is much appreciated!
     
  • Comment #3 (Posted by an unknown user)
    Rating
    nice work, leanred alot thnaks alot
     
  • Comment #4 (Posted by an unknown user)
    Rating
    Awesome read. Very informative, you covered the bases well.
     
  • Comment #5 (Posted by an unknown user)
    Rating
    Great article
     
  • Comment #6 (Posted by an unknown user)
    Rating
    Very good overall explanitation!
     
  • Comment #7 (Posted by an unknown user)
    Rating
    Well written, informative article.
     
  • Comment #8 (Posted by an unknown user)
    Rating
    Great. . .Own an 04STi with Cobb Stg-2. Very informative. Thank You.
     
  • Comment #9 (Posted by an unknown user)
    Rating
    I was deciding on cobb w/ accessport or vishnu w/ there reflash and time down to wait for my ecu to be sent out and waiting to recieve. But after reading this article I will be going with cobb. thank you
     
  • Comment #10 (Posted by an unknown user)
    Rating
    Thanks man!!!
     
  • Comment #11 (Posted by an unknown user)
    Rating
    woo-hoo!

     
  • Comment #12 (Posted by an unknown user)
    Rating
    Great info... thanks very much.
     
  • Comment #13 (Posted by an unknown user)
    Rating
    nice
     
  • Comment #14 (Posted by an unknown user)
    Rating
    Awesome write-up...I learned a lot just from reading this. Thanks for taking the time to pull all this info together, I am def leaning toward the COBB unit now!

     
  • Comment #15 (Posted by an unknown user)
    Rating
    Incredibly proper & rightly pertinent information.
    Thanks for the insight man.

    L8
     
  • Comment #16 (Posted by an unknown user)
    Rating
    Keep ypur eye out for a White MY06 STI, thanks to you i now understand how and what i could do with MY06. Keep an eye out 4 me. thanks for the advice. hopefully ill be able to show you MY06.
    fritz
     
  • Comment #17 (Posted by an unknown user)
    Rating
    oh im fridgie on IWSTi. like i said keep an eye out.
    fritz
     
Submit Comment